I’ve read the arguments for the city’s best baseball team, and have based my decision on something completely arbitrary (in the spirit of this great debate.)

Here it is. Josh wins, because he worked in candy. Nicole almost took the win with a fun spot for cocktails, but Baby Ruth’s sweet, salty goodness tipped the scales in favor of the Yanks.

How can you resist this?

Editor’s note: The origin of Baby Ruth’s name is hotly debated. The bar’s creator, Curtiss Candy Company, claimed it was named for President Grover Cleveland’s daughter Ruth, but that doesn’t make much sense since it was 17 years after her death. Read more here. In the meantime, I’m sticking with Josh’s explanation.

Another Babe, also irresistable.